Trade Wars Are Economic Self-Mutilation

Trade Wars

One must wonder about President Donald Trump’s personal knowledge about American history in general, and more particularly, about our past tariff wars. Has he never heard of the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act?

The alarming details and the disastrous results of that previous Trump-like tariff war in 1930 are described in the current newsletter of David Tanzer, JD, a friend and a leading international attorney with 30 years’ experience in estate planning. It’s worthy of review.

Tanzer says:

The popular view among leading economists, business leaders, historians and well-read leaders of the free world is that the 1930 Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act was a leading cause of the Great Depression, which ushered in WWII. At a minimum, there is consensus that the passage of the Act greatly exacerbated the problems of the 1930s.

Perhaps at least the president should pause to consider the advice of the philosopher George Santayana: “Those who do not remember the past are condemned to repeat it.”

With even a cursory understanding, Trump might come to understand that the last thing America and the world needs is the international economic self-mutilation of a trade war.


Nobody Wins Trade Wars

Free trade is such a basic, accepted principle of sound economics that we rarely feel the need to mention it. Free trade is the underlying premise of our views on profitable foreign and domestic investing, offshore banking and sound asset protection.

Freedom to do business worldwide is a personal luxury too many Americans take for granted — the unfettered ability to move capital, goods and services across international borders with minimum governmental interference.

Belief in free market economics and support for the very real benefits of free international trade go hand in hand.

Now comes a bellicose Trump, carelessly imposing U.S. government tariffs on imported steel and aluminum. His stated goal is to protect existing American jobs and create new employment. But as Politico reports, Trump is “threatening to turn allies into enemies at home and abroad with his trade pronouncements.”

On Monday, an analysis by Bloomberg Economics predicted a full-blown trade war could cost the global economy $470 billion, shrinking the global economy by 0.5% by 2020. These numbers support German Chancellor Angela Merkel’s warning that “nobody will win” a global trade conflict.

In spite of many trade problems, Tyler Cowen, a professor of economics at George Mason University, reminds us: “The last 20 years have brought the world more trade, more globalization and more economic growth than in any previous such period in history.”

Irrational Isolationism

Some politicians repeatedly accuse U.S. businesses with foreign activities of destroying American jobs — when in fact, these businesses create millions of U.S. jobs that depend on trade.

Politicians’ irrational fear of free trade dates to the first U.S. Secretary of the Treasury, Alexander Hamilton, who advocated tariffs to help protect infant industries in his “Report on Manufactures.” Smoot, Hawley and Trump echo this irrational and damaging isolationism.

Rational economists understand that international trade works best with free cooperation, not cutthroat competition. International trade as economic conflict, also known as trade wars, creates a real threat to American profits and U.S. jobs.

If I thought he might read it, I’d send the president a copy of the classic What Is Free Trade? by Frédéric Bastiat. It might lessen his suspicions about economic relations with foreigners, a tendency to distrust “others” about which I commented recently.

Bastiat wisely explains that commercial transactions create a reciprocal dependence that “constitutes the very essence of society. To sever natural interrelations is not to make oneself independent, but to isolate oneself completely.”

Economic isolation may be Trump’s unwitting goal, but America should not be made to suffer such a dangerous fate.

Yours for liberty,

Bob Bauman, JD

Legal Counsel, Banyan Hill Publishing

Editor’s Note: Every day, new threats are silently being unleashed upon you and your family. Threats from an increasingly desperate government … threats from greedy lawyers … and threats from dangerous cyber thieves. But with Bob’s Forbidden Knowledge, you and your family can have peace of mind knowing that your assets are protected from these dangerous attacks. To get your free copy today, simply click here now.

  • Angel Simms

    I already knew this, I also knew Trump is Bad News, But so was the other real crook, we all know who she is, it’s like both of them need go to jail. Trump is start it a new war, just not trade war either. maybe it’s many of them. And all stuck and middle of it. Can you say Globle war. Make my job harder, and can’t tell what that job is, so please ask.

  • John P

    First of all I believe these tariffs are a bargaining chip to get fairer trade deals throughout the world. Right way they criticize
    the President but lets face it we have lost thousands of jobs from so called trade deals made by Clinton on NAFTA and GATT. It is ok to put tariffs on American goods overseas but it is not ok for us to do the same. That is riduculous.

  • John P

    Free trade also means Fair Trade and we have not had fair trade in decades.

  • Brent Lagesse

    Did no one else notice that countries could individually negotiate exemption? This is a ploy to improve our position in work trade. Weather it will work or not, weather it starts a trade war or not, is the choice of those other nations. Are they willing to play ball or not? Up to them.

  • John P

    I used to be a Democrat not any more . I worked for a large company and belonged to a union, Dem’s always said they had our backs which was the biggest lie ever. Democrats only want the middle class to pay for their agenda of taking care of all the people who don’t work and all the illegals coming in and give them all the freebies. Not anymore,

  • ACE!!!!

    Europe places a Tariff on the U.S.? Why is it that they are complaining about this coming to them? We pay out the A…. on tariff’s that support these countries government! We do not get anything back in fair trade for our business? If our American business assets are over looked in these countries getting a free ride with no tariff’s placed on them but they place them on us> This is not balancing for the American people’s feelings even if these people do not understand! It could have a negative reaction within the American people in that we feel like we are being taken advantage of!

  • Chip Markle

    Wrong, in two respects, at least, 1) this was limited and intended to preserve two vital defense industries. security. 2) The free domestic market works, bumpy, perhaps, but it works.