This Chart Shows the Government Strangled the Economy

Economists generally say government spending is good for the economy. But, as with anything, sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.

Governments operate on many levels. We usually think of federal spending and question how much is enough. But state and local governments also spend significant amounts of money. The chart below adds up spending at the federal, state and local levels and divides the sum by gross domestic product (GDP). This shows the size of the government over time.

Economists generally say government spending is good for the economy. But, as with anything, sometimes you can have too much of a good thing.

(Source: Federal Reserve)

The government now accounts for 47.6% of GDP. The good news is spending fell from its 2009 peak of 53.8%. The bad news is that the downtrend appears to have ended.

Some government spending is needed. The government builds and maintains roads and other infrastructure. Education and defense spending is necessary. Some level of spending on health care and social programs is needed.

The problem comes from how the government gets money to spend. It must extract money from the people who produce goods and services in the private sector. If the government takes too much money from the private sector, the private sector can’t grow quickly.

Too much government spending could explain why the recovery from the last recession has been so slow. There are other causes for slow growth, but recent research shows a link between changes in government spending and the level of economic growth in France and Canada.

For now, Washington is focusing on a tax cut, but the best action is probably a spending cut. This is true at all levels of government. Until we see that, the economy might continue growing slowly.


Michael Carr, CMT
Editor, Peak Velocity Trader

P.S. Most of the research on earnings has looked at returns over a period of six to nine months, which would obviously expose investors to all types of corporate, economic, political and market risks. Chad Shoop wanted to capture profits in a much shorter period of time to minimize the risks as much as possible, so he created a brand-new investment strategy. His system lets him boost profits much higher than the 10% or so gain that a strong earnings announcement typically produces. To find out more about Chad’s amazing research service, click here.


A government that spends has to have a surplus. Spending driven by debt is a math failure. Common sense proves it. Our debts are what is choking America. Government ignoring our debts and adding more debt spending will not make the debts go away. The debts will get even larger and those debts will be America’s demise. Ignoring the debt and adding to it is exactly why we have this debt. Doing the same things again and again and again and expecting different results is insane.

Leave a Reply